If you’ve been reading the gaming news recently, you’ve probably seen all the articles about Valve’s failed ‘paid video game mods’ controversy. Put simply, they added a feature to Steam that let video game modders charge for their work, and then caused such a split in public opinion that the feature was then canned after literally less than 24 hours.
But while this tale was an interesting one to read about, I’m going to come out and say it now:
I do not like the idea of paid video game mods. And I really, really don’t see much good coming from being able to pay for fan made modifications of existing games.
Now, some may ask why I feel this way. Indeed, some may especially ask it given my involvement in the ROM hacking and fan game scenes for the Mario and Zelda franchises. Heck, if I was playing a ton of PC games, I would probably be making video game mods all the time, given my involvement in the console game equivalent scenes.
But even with all that in mind, I don’t want to see paid modifications of video games. Or for the modding scenes to go all ‘professional’ like some people seem to advocate. Why? Well, here are some reasons…
1. Charging for Mods Disincentives Sharing Resources
Firstly, have you seen how many great websites exist to share resources for game mods? You’ve not only got general ones like Nexus Mods, but also game specific ones like various ones for Doom wads and others for games as obscure as Jurassic Park Trespasser.
Above: Yes, this actually exists.
Add in the ROM hacking and fan game scene sites, and that’s a lot of great free resources you can find after just a minute or two using Google.
But do you know why they’re so common?
Because people are involved for reasons involving a passion for the subject. Because the people involved in this scene want to help people, and with no money involved, do so by making it easier for other people to make their own games.
But what happens if the scene starts going paid?
Answer? The potential loss of all these free tools and resources. After all, why give out for free what you can sell for a large amount of money? Or for that matter, why give out stuff free if people are only going to use it in paid releases and give you zero credit in the process?
The idea of paid mods disincentives people from sharing things like tools, models, textures and other resources for use within the modding scene. And given that these things existing is one of the elements that makes such scenes so successful in the first place…
2. Many Great Mods aren’t ‘Above Board’
Another reason I don’t trust the idea of paid mods, is because it could theoretically stop the release of the super successful mods that are based around referencing other works.
For example, Skyrim had a Lord of the Rings mod, one that basically changed the entire setting to Middle Earth. Think either the Tolkien estate or Warner Brothers gave permission for that?
Above: Many good examples
Or how about the old Doom wad based on Batman? That was fantastic, yet it’d never be something you could release in a ‘paid’ environment. The copyright and trademark lawyers would smash it to pieces within hours…
And the list goes on. Super Smash Bros? Has tons of custom characters, stages, songs and other things that the original owners likely never gave permission to include in the game.
And outside of those types of game mods, you get the ROM hacking world. Brutal Mario is pretty much 99% crossover content:
None of that was licensed by anyone.
So why is this a problem? Why is it an issue to have ‘crossover’ mods and content if they’re not sold?
Because if other mods are sold, various legal issues could crop up about what the developers are responsible for. If that leads people to believe they ‘encouraged’ the Lord of Rings mod for Skyrim, someone involved with the IP could go after the developer for it. And then there’s the dangerous possibility that they could force ALL mods to be released only via some ‘official’ platform, which would then kill these mods off altogether. Do we really want to lose all the great wish fulfilment crossover/total conversion game mods that are out there just so more minor stuff can sold for a couple of bucks?