The 3D Platformer Comparison; Yooka Laylee, A Hat in Time or Lobodestroyo?

For a rather long period of time, 3D platformers were not a particularly popular genre. Okay, they were big in the days of the N64 and Playstation 1, but with Rare’s decline and the FPS genre taking off, the days of 3D mascot platformers seemingly came to an end.

But as with everything else, Kickstarter came to the rescue. Inspired by classic collectathon platformers like Super Mario 64, Banjo Kazooie and Donkey Kong 64 (among others), three different teams have funded new projects in the style of the N64 games we all know and love. Those being? A Hat in Time, Lobodestroyo and Yooka Laylee. What’s more, all three have at least some involvement from ex Rare staff (often Grant Kirkhope). Here are the Kickstarter trailers for the three:

http://www.dailymotion.com/video/x10k9nq_a-hat-in-time-kickstarter-trailer_videogames

But which one is best? Which of the three big 3D platformers of the 2010s is going to be the true spiritual successor to Banjo Kazooie? Let’s find out, in the 3D platformer comparison!

The Story and Characters

Time is falling apart, and the brave interstellar travelling Hat Kid has to collect the pieces and put them back together away. All while racing against the evil Moustache Girl and her wishes of using time for evil purposes.

Above: The basic trailer for A Hat in Time, showing some of the story and levels.

Lobodestroyo’s plot on the other hand, is a tad more complicated. Probably better to let them explain it to be honest:

The legendary Lobodestroyo is the sentinel of Costa Lucha. His wolf pack protects its citizens by locking away villains who threaten the peace, and maintain order from high atop Mt. Justice! At least he did…

Mutt, the runt of the wolf pack litter, wakes up to find Mt. Justice in ruins; His wolf pack brothers missing; and the Lobodestroyo’s championship belt strewn across his destroyed temple. To top it off the maximum security lockup has been breached and the 10 members of La Liga de Los Villanos have escaped. Determined to avenge his brethren and prove his worth, Mutt dons the championship belt and takes up the mantle of his fallen hero.

Tag-teaming with the luchador spirit Dorado, who dwells in the mystical belt, Mutt explores the hub city of Costa Lucha and unlocks new areas, while he attempts to track down and unmask the evil villains who have overrun each game world.

And what’s the plot for Yooka-Laylee? That’s actually a good question, since the Kickstarter page and official website don’t really give away the plot. All we know is that Yooka and Laylee (the chameleon guy with no pants and the bat with the big nose respectively) are trying to collect Pagies in a bunch of worlds loosely based around books.

Yooka-Laylee_artwork

Above: Pretty much what we currently know about the plot of Yooka-Laylee, in one picture.

So what’s the best plot here? Depends on whether you want a simpler excuse to go jumping on heads or a complex excuse to save the world. Lobodestroyo has the more thought out storyline, A Hat in Time has the easier to explain one. We’d probably go with Lobodestroyo ourselves, though the lack of a complete Yooka-Laylee storyline/plot summary means it’s not a fair comparison at this point.

Art Style

So now onto the art side of things. To make it a bit fairer, we’ll divide this section into two parts; the concept art and the in game graphics. This is because the quality of in game graphics depends on heavily on far the game is into development, whereas the concept art gives an idea about what the team are going for aesthetically.

On the concept art level then, what game does better? Well, that’s a difficult one given how all three games have a different style going on. A Hat in Time seems to be inspired more by the cel shaded art of The Wind Waker and Jet Set Radio, whereas Lobodestroyo takes influence from comic books and Yooka Laylee flat out goes for an updated Banjo Kazooie vibe for things. They all look fantastic too:

Yooka-Laylee Art

Above: Yooka-Laylee’s concept art looks absolutely gorgeous.

But honestly? On this count, we’d probably go for Lobodestroyo. Why? Because it seems more original in terms of the style it’s going for. Sure, the other two look good, but they also seem a bit… well, safe. Like they’re trying to take as much inspiration from Banjo and co as possible without really building on it in any way.

 

On the other hand, there’s something about Lobodestroyo’s style that stands out a bit more, at least in terms of the concept art. Look at this stuff:

Lobodestroyoart2 Lobodestroyoart1

You’ve got a luchador fighting wacky animal villains from the ‘La Liga de Los Villanos’ in the style of Mega Man. Add a bunch of quirky and surprisingly ‘dark’ settings (like a high security prison and a theme park castle filled with cheering minions of the villain) and stuff like the tank shown above, and you’ve got a game which would have been a highly original title even back in the days when collectathons were two a penny.

In game on the other hand? That’s a hard one. All three have decent enough graphics (even for games that are in alpha or early beta stages). But we’d probably give it to A Hat in Time, simply because of some of the awesome aesthetics in its later levels. I mean, look at this mansion level:

That’s creepy as hell to be honest. And the art style with all the shadows and dynamic lighting is done in such an amazing way that I just have to give this one to the game. Will Yooka-Laylee or Lobodestroyo come up with something equally as great for their future levels? They most probably will, all three games seem like they’ll have all manner of creative looking levels and graphics. But for now, A Hat in Time wins this one.

Music (featuring Grant Kirkhope)

What?

Out of all three projects, all of them feature music by Grant Kirkhope. Given that he composed the soundtrack for the Banjo Kazooie games and Donkey Kong 64, that very likely means they’ll retain the feel of Rare’s classics just fine.

Above: Some songs he previously worked on  You should recognise all of them even without the pictures

And while Lobodestroyo will only be getting one song by Grant, that song (the boss one) will be remixed by Gooseworx into a whole bunch of catchy themes.  It will also be accompanied by a bunch of (likely equally good) music by Gooseworx.

But we’re probably going to have to give this one to Yooka Laylee. Why? Because not only does Grant Kirkhope compose music for it, but so does David Wise. You know, the guy who brought us such classic Donkey Kong Country songs as Stickerbrush Symphony and Aquatic Ambience. So while all the games have at least classic Rare styled soundtracks and Grant Kirkhope provides songs for multiple projects, we think the game with multiple members of Rare’s music staff composing for it is probably going to do better on the music front.

Gameplay and Level Design

And now, the most important part of these games. Which one is better in terms of gameplay?

Well, we can’t really say much yet, since we haven’t played it. So let’s look at some of the videos showing the game being played by other (slightly luckier) testers:

For A Hat in Time, we have two full levels showed off. The mafia filled beach town, and the creepy haunted mansion shown earlier:

It looks pretty good, though the game feels a bit more like Mario Sunshine than a Nintendo 64 era game. Not bad, just a bit different.

For Lobodestroyo, we don’t have another footage online to show what it really looks like. I mean, I came across this test area tech demo:

But that doesn’t really say much. You get a bit of the walking animation in a test room. Nothing else seems to exist yet, outside of concept art and things.

For Yooka-Laylee, we’ve got a small amount of gameplay footage that was shown off earlier this year:

It looks surprisingly good (for about three months of development), though we can’t really judge much in the way of level or game design from it, since the tech demo type stuff shows no real missions or standard gameplay.

We’re not to going to judge this yet, because we only have full levels for one of the games.

Nostalgia

Well, all three came with fake Nintendo 64 cartridges and boxes for the people longingly wishing to be taken back to those days. For instance, here are the retro boxes and cartridges for the games (given out as Kickstarter rewards):

HatInTimeNintendo64 YookaLayleeN64 LobodestroyoN64

Granted, the Nintendo 64 cartridges provided aren’t functional, since none of the games would ever actually run on a Nintendo 64. But hey, it is a nice retraux touch to have, right?

Kickstarter Results

A Hat in Time raised $296,340 on Kickstarter, Lobodestroyo raised $43,831 on Kickstarter and Yooka-Laylee raised £2,090,104 ($3,265,160.47) on said service. So based on that, Yooka-Laylee is obviously the one out of the three that people showed most interest in financially.

Either way, it’s still good news all around. All three games met their funding goals and are hence currently in development. Regardless of which one you want to play most, it’s been a good result.

Console Platforms

Here are the consoles supported by the three titles:

System A Hat in Time Lobodestroyo Yooka-Laylee
PC Yes Yes Yes
Mac Yes Yes Yes
Linux No Yes Yes
Wii U Yes Yes Yes
PS4 No Yes Yes
Xbox One No Yes Yes
Ouya No Yes No

As you can see, Yooka-Laylee and Lobodestroyo are available on pretty much the same console platforms (or in other words, all of them that have any real market share at the moment). The latter is also available (or at least being made for) Ouya, despite said system failing miserably and not really being all that important at this point in time.

Ouya

Above: The now failed Ouya system whose owners will now also be able to play Lobodestroyo

On the other hand, A Hat in Time is seemingly PC and Wii U specific, with support for other console platforms being currently unplanned. So it loses out a bit on that front, given how its competition will also be available to buy for the Xbox One or PS4 (for those people who aren’t really major Nintendo fans).

So while it’s extremely close, we’d give this one to Lobodestroyo. Yes the Ouya isn’t exactly a relevant system any more, but hey, it is technically going to support one more system than Yooka-Laylee.

Thought the real winners are probably Wii U owners, given that they’re getting three full-fledged 3D platformers around the same time, on a system that’s otherwise mostly of devoid of games and that’s been near completely abandoned by third parties.

Potential Issues

And now, something a bit more controversial. What things could possibly go wrong with each of these games? Well, for a Hat in Time, we’ve heard about some issues involving the staff that occurred some time in the past.  But assuming that’s now irrelevant, we’d say the only issue is that the game’s Wii U focus might turn out to be an issue for it.  Seems like going Wii U and PC exclusive is a good way to lose a lot of potential customers.

For Lobodestroyo… it’s probably the money that’s the big concern. You see, while about $44,000 dollars is a nice amount to raise when your game is mostly unknown to the world at large, it’s also peanuts as far as funding a large scale 3D game goes. Okay, they’re splitting the game into parts, so that eases up some of the pressure, and outside funding probably exists for this project… but the amount raised by the Kickstarter is still really low. Heck, it’d still be a tight budget if the game was entirely 2D and had little to no real ambition whatsoever.

Banjo-Tooie_Coverart

Above: Banjo-Tooie was probably not made on a budget of 44,000 dollars…

And finally, our only concern with Yooka-Laylee is that the level of ambition shown by the devs might be a little too high. Okay, they’ve raised a lot of money. But they’ve also promised an ever increasing list of features that get ever more ambitious as the list goes down. Co-op mode, multiplayer mini games, 2.5D mine carts, professional translations, full orchestrated soundtrack, free DLC…

Yooka-LayleeStretchGoals

Above: Yooka-Laylee has an impressive list of stretch goals.  They’d just better make sure they’re not spreading themselves too thin trying to complete them…

That’s a pretty big ask for any game, so try and make sure you’re not biting off more than you can chew.

And the Winner Is?

The fans, because we get to play more 3D platformers.

Oh, you wanted to know which of the three games mentioned above looks to the best one? Well personally, we’d say Yooka-Laylee looks to have a stronger team, that Lobodestroyo has the more interesting concept and storyline and that A Hat in Time is a more rounded game that comes somewhere between them.

Either way, while it’s a very close call so far (there’s just one point worth of difference between the best and worst game in this comparison), we’re just about going to give it to Yooka-Laylee, since it has the most experienced team behind it and looks to be the game most likely to live up to expectations.  The fact it made over 2 million pounds

Don’t take it too negatively though; they’re all worth supporting.

Resources

Official Sites

Official site for A Hat in Time

Official site for Yooka-Laylee/Playtonic Games

Official site for Lobodestroyo

Kickstarter Pages

A Hat in Time Kickstarter

Lobodestroyo Kickstarter

Yooka-Laylee Kickstarter

Discussion Forums

Playtonic/Yooka-Laylee Forum on DK Vine

Lobodestroyo Topic at DK Vine

Playtonic Games Subreddit

Playtonic Games Official Forum

Social Media Accounts

A Hat in Time on Twitter

Gears for Breakfast on Twitter

Lobodestroyo on Twitter

Playtonic Games on Twitter

 

Liveblog

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
2 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Link 70222
Link 70222(@link-70222)
5 years ago

I'm super excited for Yooka Laylee since it'll probably be really good. I saw a little gameplay of A Hat in Time, but it didn't keep my interest so I might look out for it in the future, and I've never heard of Lobodestroyo and after watching the trailer… I have no words.

But, yeah, I'll totally buy Yooka Laylee when it comes out.